Want to CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 44 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

Wrung Out

Donna Granger sat on the edge of her neatly made bed, her back straight, hands resting in her lap, fingers entwined so tightly her knuckles blanched white. The soft evening light filtered through the sheer curtains, casting a faint, warm glow over the pristine bedroom. Everything was in its place: the sleek, modern furniture, the carefully chosen art prints, the expensive bedding she’d insisted on last year during their remodel. But nothing about the room felt comforting now. It was just a space, sterile and suffocating.

She stared at the closed door, her jaw clenched, ing the way Hank had greeted her when she got home. Like it was nothing. Like everything was normal. He’d smiled, reached for her like he always did, tried to pull her into a hug, leaned in for a kiss. She’d recoiled before she could stop herself, her body stiffening with disgust she didn’t even understand at first. It wasn’t that she hated him; she didn’t. But the touch felt wrong. Inappropriate. Unwelcome.

And he’d seen it in her face.

Donna had loved Hank. They'd built a life together, raised two children, ed each other as they grew their careers. Not that any of that mattered. Not now.

Hank was in the kitchen, alone, pretending to clean up, his frustration thick in the air like humidity before a storm. She could hear the faint clatter of dishes, the sharp scrape of a chair being pushed back too hard. He was angry, confused, and Donna didn’t blame him. She’d been distant for days, cold to his attempts at affection, dismissive when he asked what was wrong.

But what could she say? That everything she believed about relationships, about men, even about herself had been wrong? That she didn’t see, couldn't see, Hank in the same way anymore? He was still her husband, but only really in name. A formality. He had done nothing wrong, but it didn't change the facts. Donna Granger could never be the wife that he needed, that he wanted. All of it, their entire life together, a mistake.

The thought of trying to explain it to him made her stomach twist.

Donna paused in her thoughts. She wasn't entirely right. Donna's career in real estate law was so successful because of her eye for detail. When something was off, she was usually the first to notice it. How could every part of her relationship with Hank have been a mistake? If Hank and Donna hadn't fallen in love and gotten married, Joey, her Joey, would have never come along. She needed to that. If for nothing else, she should at least be thankful to Hank for that.

Still, all the benefits of their relationship was in the past. She had the future to think about. There was a lot of uncertainty in her future. She knew that so much had changed, but it didn't mean that she had much control over her destiny. Joey, her perfect guy, could just come home and give her an order that would completely change the course of her life. Of course she’d follow his instructions; it wasn’t as if she had any choice. If her perfect guy said jump, she asked how high!

She stood abruptly, pacing the room in small, controlled steps. Her heels clicked softly against the hardwood floor, a sound she usually found satisfying, professional, powerful. Now it just echoed the restless energy churning inside her.

Trying to calm her mind, she allowed it to drift to Joey. Joey, who wasn’t just her son anymore, not in the simple, familiar way he used to be. He was… more. He wasn’t like Hank. He wasn’t like any man she’d ever known. Women, especially the kind of girls who’d been like her in high school, the ones everyone thought were untouchable, those girls didn’t want the old-fashioned idea of the perfect guy. They didn’t want Hank with his dad jokes and his dependable job and his casual kisses. They wanted Joey. Joey was the new perfect guy.

It was undeniable. A proven fact. She’d seen it. Felt it.

She ed their dinner, their car ride, intimate moments shared between two people, reweaving themselves together in a new fashion, their context redefined. The feeling of Joey’s hand on her thigh as she drove filled her with a safe, stable, dependable knowledge. She was living out her destiny. Joey was touching her whenever, however he wanted. He was learning to see her for who she really was, for who he had explained to her she should be.

Her reflection caught in the mirror as she ed, and she paused, studying herself. She still looked the same—sharp, confident, put-together. Her dark brown hair was pulled back into a sleek ponytail, not a strand out of place. Her tailored blouse and pencil skirt hugged her figure, professional and precise. But underneath, everything was different. Her core had shifted.

The door creaked open behind her, and she turned to see Hank standing there, his brow furrowed, his eyes a mixture of concern and frustration. There was a time she had ired his large frame, his square jaw. She could still the feeling of his rough hands on her body, being thrown on the bed, nights of ion and romance.

Every memory felt cold, dry, dusty. All emotion, all warmth, had been wrung out of them like a washcloth spent, about to be discarded in the laundry pile.

"Donna," he said softly, his voice tentative, "Are we going to talk about this?"

She didn’t answer. She couldn’t. The words stuck in her throat.

"I don’t know what I did," he continued, stepping into the room, his hands raised slightly like he was approaching a wild animal, "But whatever it is, I’m sorry. Just… tell me."

She wanted to yell at him, to tell him it wasn’t about something he did. But it was easier to let him think that. It was easier than explaining that he just… wasn’t right anymore.

"I’m tired," she said flatly, crossing her arms over her chest.

"Tired?" His voice sharpened, his patience thinning. "Donna, you’ve been tired for days. You’ve been distant. Cold. You come home late with Joey like... like I’m not even here. What’s going on?"

Her heart raced. She looked away, staring at the framed diploma on the wall, the perfect lines of her carefully curated life.

"I don’t want to fight," she whispered.

"Then don’t fight. Just talk to me."

She shook her head, "I can’t."

His jaw tightened, "Why not?"

Because you’re not the man I thought you were. Because you’re not the man I need.

But she didn’t say it. She couldn’t. Instead, she met his gaze, her expression blank, her voice cool.

"I’m going to take a shower."

And she walked past him, leaving him standing there, alone in the doorway, his confusion and hurt heavy in the silence behind her.

What's next?

More fun
Want to CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)